‘Even if union can happen, why must it be my duty?’
My friend the sceptic says: Suppose the union can happen, why is it my duty? Good question. There are two duties here, and the second rests on the first.
The state’s duty
A state exists to protect its people’s pursuit of life, liberty, and knowledge. To do that it needs capacity: the means to do the job. That means, among other things, the ability to defend the country from enemies foreign and domestic, to provide a stable economic environment, and to feed and school everyone. Where capacity is missing, good intentions are not enough. So the first duty is the state’s: to acquire the capacity it lacks. For countries too small to build it alone, that capacity comes through union. And let me be clear, “too small” does not refer to size, it refers to the ability to produce what is promised – in other words capacity.
Indeed, the human story, whether rooted in Divine Creation or in evolution, is a search for capacity. If you hold to Creation, it runs from the first family, Adam and Eve, to their descendants in bands, clans and tribes, to villages and chiefdoms, to states of all sorts: kingdoms, empires, nation-states, and now unions of states. If you prefer evolution, it runs from the primordial soup to single cells, and over billions of years to cells that clumped together into complex organisms like you and me. Either way, the road has never been a straight line, and no one claims it was. But the pull toward cooperation is constant, and what drives it is capacity, not necessarily size.
The people’s duty
The promise of capacity is what gives a state its claim on us in the first place. Without that promise, it has none. Even animals in the wild leave land that cannot sustain them, but a people should not have to flee its own home. We are therefore entitled to a state able to deliver what it promised, and we have the right and the duty to insist upon it. This insistence may take many forms, but for our purposes, we ask, we vote, and we demand. A right unclaimed is a gun without a bullet. We load it with a question, a vote, and a demand.
Those who asked before us
Kwame Nkrumah gave Africa a commandment: seek ye first the political kingdom, and all else shall be added unto you. In 1963, in Addis Ababa, he told Africa’s new leaders to do exactly that, and warned: “We must unite now or perish.” That was Nkrumah telling the 32 countries at the time that they lacked the capacity to produce what their governments had promised. But they were endowed with eyes, not ears. He was not heard. They signed a charter for a club of countries instead. That is now 63 years of promises, made for us, in rooms we were not in. None of those promises was ever put to us. We are ancillary – afterthoughts – to the mighty machinations of men on thrones. That is the reality on the ground. Still, we are the people. We occupy higher ground and dare them to climb it. Even in the face of the greatest odds, right is right, and is never wrong. We are right.
Bread first, then the wall
Think of a simple bargain made by a people who are no strangers to catastrophe. Famine has visited them, and raiders have followed. So in every village the village leaders won the people’s trust, took their grain, and promised two things: bread for all, and a wall to keep them safe. But no village can bake or build alone. One has flour but no baker, another bakers but no flour, another both but no oven, and none has the workers to raise a wall. Everyone knows what is owed. And if no village can do it alone, it is the village leaders’ duty to find the means: pool the flour, the bakers, the ovens and the labor, and work as one. First the people must be fed. Then, fed and working as one, they can raise the wall. Until then they go hungry and exposed, and have every right to insist. A state is no different. For a country too small to bake alone, the means is union.
See what 54 countries, each baking alone, have wrought. Fifty-four budgets, and famine still comes. Fifty-four borders between a trader and her market. Fifty-four mouths, each claiming to speak for us without asking. Fifty-four armies that turn their guns on us, the unfortunate, the despised. But I think of one child in a famine in Sudan. A photograph showed him, starving, and behind him a vulture, waiting for its feast.
I lost my dad while I was away. I love my dad and I think of him often, but he does not haunt me. I lost my mom while I was away. I desperately love and miss my mom and I think of her often, but she does not haunt me. I have never met this child, but I think of him often, and he haunts me. Over the decades, try as I have, I simply cannot forget him. He sits on my shoulder and compels me to acknowledge his humanity – every day. And I mean every day. Then it recently occurred to me, he persists because he is my own, alone, starved of hope and love and the safety of numbers. He is my child without bread and walls, and I am angry, and hurt, and ashamed for I have failed in all the ways that matter. Read it again. And again. And again.
We did more than pay taxes and give our trust to the state. We gave up rights to defend ourselves alone, to settle our own quarrels, and to be our own law. We did it because we saw that alone we lacked the capacity to protect ourselves, and that by pooling into a country we could gain it. The state was a means to an end, and so is union. That was the compact. We are not asking to leave it. We are asking the state to keep it. From the beginning the state promised to protect, for all, the rights we kept: life, liberty, and the pursuit of knowledge. But look around you and tell yourself, hand to heart, if the state has delivered. Tell yourself, that you do not want for food or water. That you do not fear your government. That you are exactly where you want to be, and you swear it. Is the border your gate or your wall? I told you to read it again, and again, and again. In your room alone and in the dark, when you fall to your knees in a silent scream, you’ll realize the vulture and the child haunt you too.
Let us reckon with our losses. Let us see what we have been denied, what has been taken from us, and what might have been. Seventy-one trillion dollars if we are cautious, two hundred and two if we are bold, with the might to keep it. Let us be rightly indignant at the deception, the betrayal and the indignity. Let us grieve for the lives diminished, the opportunities lost, the children abandoned and the generations made to wait. What wouldn’t they take from us that profit demands? Our obedience? Everything but our obedience; they will let us keep that as our most valuable possession.
But we forget ourselves. We did not build the world to become its charge. We were not born to be dependents, nor were we made to stand on our knees. This is not ordained, and no one may command it.
Let us be angry that what was promised to us has not come to pass, and that we have been asked, time and again, to accept less. We shall not. Do not accept as your destiny what is merely the consequence of your dispossession. We are blessed with people, land and each other, and we shall build a house, where the light stays on, the table is full, and vultures never stalk our children. Our political kingdom, our house, our union.
Two duties, then. The state’s: to build the ability to deliver what it promised. Ours: to insist that it does. Nkrumah gave us a commandment for kings and presidents: seek ye first the political kingdom. Here is one, plainly said, for the rest of us. Build the house. Union is the way, a promise in rock and stone.
Ask. Vote. Petition. Demand. Insist. Build the house. Through every storm they may conjure, build the house. Build it wide and build it strong, that all things hurled may break against its walls. Build it now, and build it for the ages. Build it, whatever the cost. I swear, you will not regret it.
The sceptic asks: fine, but how do 54 countries become one? That is next . . . .
By Morro K Ceesay