I agree that we must be careful not to undermine the confidence of students and graduates through sweeping and unsupported generalisations.
Indeed, UTG has an important place in the development of The Gambia’s human capital. Its graduates should be judged fairly, just as the institution itself should be assessed against appropriate academic and professional standards.
However, protecting the university’s reputation must not mean avoiding legitimate scrutiny. A credible university should welcome constructive examination of its programmes, teaching quality, research output, assessment systems, graduate employability and academic standards.
The institution must continuously evaluate whether its graduates are adequately prepared for the demands of the modern economy and public service.
It must also create an environment in which academic staff have the time, resources and professional support to undertake meaningful research.
The ambition should be for UTG not merely to be respected nationally, but to develop the academic credibility and research capacity necessary to compete regionally and internationally.
Staff welfare and the importance of a healthy institutional culture
A university’s academic mission depends heavily on the people who deliver it. Lecturers, researchers, administrators, technical personnel and other employees all contribute to the institution’s effectiveness. Their welfare, professional development and working conditions must therefore be central to university management.
The minister’s comments about lecturer workloads and the university’s internal arrangements raise an important point: academic responsibilities must be allocated fairly, transparently and in accordance with established policies.
Teaching workloads should allow lecturers to perform their responsibilities effectively while leaving appropriate space for research, supervision, professional development and other academic duties.
Equally, concerns about staff remuneration, salary delays, promotions and professional progression deserve serious attention.
A university cannot expect its employees to deliver excellence if the institutional environment is characterised by uncertainty, inadequate communication or unresolved grievances.
Management must engage staff constructively, while staff associations must also recognise their responsibility to contribute to institutional stability and the effective delivery of the university’s mission.
A healthy university culture is built on mutual respect, fairness, professional standards and confidence in institutional procedures.
The need for stronger institutional communication and collaboration
One broader lesson I draw from the interview is the importance of communication between the higher education ministry, governing council, university management, staff and students.
Many institutional disagreements become more difficult to resolve when communication breaks down, information is withheld or stakeholders begin to rely on informal accounts and public exchanges.
A university should have established mechanisms for regular engagement between its principal stakeholders. Difficult issues should be discussed early, responsibilities should be understood and decisions should be communicated clearly.
The ministry should maintain constructive engagement with the university without weakening the responsibilities of its governing structures.
The UTG Governing Council should provide effective oversight and maintain an appropriate working relationship with the vice-chancellor.
The vice-chancellor should lead through consultation, professionalism and accountability.
Staff and students should have meaningful opportunities to raise concerns and participate in discussions affecting their welfare and the university’s future.
This is not a call for everybody to agree on everything. Universities are intellectual communities, and disagreement is often necessary for progress. The objective should be to ensure that disagreement is managed constructively rather than allowed to become institutional paralysis.
Which begs the question: What should emerge from the present controversy?
Whatever the eventual outcome of the current leadership disagreement, I hope it will lead to a stronger University of The Gambia. There are several institutional priorities that deserve attention.
First, clearer governance arrangements. The responsibilities of the higher education ministry, governing council and university management should be understood and consistently applied in accordance with the law.
Second, stronger leadership and performance management. The appointment, assessment and accountability of senior university leaders should be governed by transparent procedures and clearly established expectations.
Third, improved financial sustainability. UTG needs predictable funding, effective financial management, diversified revenue sources and stronger research and consultancy capacity.
Fourth, better student services. Transport, catering, water, Internet connectivity and learning facilities should receive sustained attention.
Fifth, staff development and welfare. The university must create an environment that attracts, retains and motivates qualified academic and administrative personnel.
Sixth, a stronger research culture. UTG should become more influential in national policy discussions, scientific inquiry, innovation and the production of knowledge relevant to Gambian society.
Finally, a culture of dialogue and institutional accountability. Disagreements should be resolved through established processes, and decisions should be guided by evidence, fairness and the university’s long-term interests.
These priorities should not depend on the identity of the person occupying the vice-chancellor’s office. They are institutional responsibilities that must continue across successive administrations.
My promised position paper: a separate and necessary contribution
I wish to make one point clear to those who have followed my earlier contributions and have encouraged me to examine the leadership controversy more closely. I have not abandoned my intention to produce the more substantive position paper that I promised.
Indeed, the higher minister’s interview has added useful context to that work. However, I believe it is important to distinguish between this present reflection and the more detailed examination that the controversy requires.
I have received perspectives, information and documents from individuals connected to different aspects of the university and the government. I am also seeking additional material, including relevant institutional records and the perspectives of key stakeholders.
The next stage requires careful examination of the Tertiary and Higher Education Act 2016, the relevant appointment arrangements, the decisions and correspondence concerning the vice-chancellor recruitment process, the work of the committees established to consider the dispute, the governing council’s responsibilities and the concerns raised by the various parties.
I also intend to seek the perspectives of the relevant institutional leaders and other stakeholders so that the eventual assessment is not based on one side’s account.
Once I have obtained and examined the additional information I am seeking, I will write the promised independent position paper.
The proposed paper on my part will go further than this article. It will examine the leadership controversy itself, assess the competing accounts against the available evidence and the applicable legal and institutional framework, and reach reasoned conclusions about where responsibility lies.
Where the evidence supports a position, I will take that position. Where a claim cannot be substantiated, I will say so. I will also offer workable recommendations for resolving the disagreement and strengthening UTG’s governance and institutional effectiveness.
I do not believe that objectivity requires a writer to remain permanently undecided. It requires the writer to examine the evidence fairly, listen to the relevant perspectives and be prepared to reach conclusions, even where those conclusions may not please everyone.
My responsibility is not to defend any individual or institution. It is to contribute honestly and constructively to a matter of national importance.
In conclusion, the University of The Gambia must emerge victorious, not merely for the sake of the institution, but for the future of higher education, national development, and generations of Gambians yet to come. Its success is a collective responsibility and a national imperative.
The university must be strengthened, protected, and empowered to fulfil its mandate as a centre of academic excellence, innovation, research, and national transformation. Ultimately, when the University of The Gambia wins, the entire nation wins.
Professor Gomez’s interview has provided an opportunity to broaden the national conversation about the University of The Gambia. It has brought attention to questions of leadership, governance, financing, student welfare, academic standards and institutional management.
These issues deserve attention beyond the current disagreement. We must recognise the achievements of the university while being honest about its challenges.
We must support government oversight while respecting the responsibilities of the university’s statutory governing structures. We must demand accountability from leaders while ensuring that due process and fairness are respected.
Above all, we must resist the temptation to reduce the future of a national university to the fortunes of particular individuals.
The University of The Gambia belongs to the Gambian people. Its future should be determined by the quality of its governance, the excellence of its academic work, the integrity of its leadership and its contribution to national development.
Leadership positions are temporary. Institutional responsibilities endure. The present controversy should therefore become an opportunity to strengthen the university rather than deepen divisions within it. There should be no personal winners or losers in this matter. The ultimate winner must be the University of The Gambia.
By Dr Ebrima Ceesay
Dr Ebrima Ceesay is a Gambian academic based in the UK.